N1 Conditions, Dependencies, and Consequences
~たら~たで: meaning, usage and examples
~たら~たで means: if... then... (new problems arise).
How to form it
<Verb た-form> + ら + <same verb た-form> + で / <い-adj かったら> + <same かった> + で / <Noun / な-adj> + なら + <same> + で
Examples
給料が上がったら上がったで、税金も高くなる。
If my salary goes up, then taxes also go up.
子供ができたらできたで、また別の悩みが出てくる。
If we have children, then new worries will arise.
車がないと不便だが、あったらあったで維持費がかかる。
Not having a car is inconvenient, but if you do have one, it costs money to maintain.
暇なときは退屈だが、忙しかったら忙しかったで疲れてしまう。
When I have free time I get bored, but when I am busy, I get worn out instead.
When to use it
Means "if X happens, then that brings its own problem (or its own good side)." The speaker notes that even a situation people want, or one they worried about, comes with something else. For example, 車があったらあったで維持費がかかる (if you have a car, then it costs money to keep).
Nuance
Conversational and slightly wry. The same word is repeated. It usually follows a contrast with the opposite situation (no car is inconvenient; having one costs money). The second half is often a new trouble, but it can also be "that is fine too": 失敗したら失敗したでいい経験だ.
Compare
Compare ば〜で: 晴れれば晴れたで暑い has the same feeling. Plain たら just states a condition: 給料が上がったら旅行する. たら〜たで adds "even this has its own side": 上がったら上がったで税金が増える.
Tip: Repeat the word exactly: 忙しかったら忙しかったで, not 忙しかったら忙しいで. Expect the opposite situation to be mentioned or implied first.
More in Conditions, Dependencies, and Consequences
- ~いかんだ / ~いかんでは / ~いかんによっては: depending on... / based on...
- ~いかんにかかわらず / ~いかんによらず / ~いかんを問わず: regardless of... / irrespective of...
- ~なくしては: without... / if it weren't for...
- ~ことなしに: without... / without doing...
- ~とあれば: if... / if it's the case that...
- ~ばそれまでだ / ~たらそれまでだ: if... then it's all over / if... that's the end of it
- ~たが最後 / ~たら最後: once... / if... (a negative result is certain)
- ~ようによっては / ~ようでは: depending on how... / if...
- ~か否か: whether or not
- ~たところで: even if... / even though...
- ~たら~ところだ: if... then... would have happened (hypothetical consequence)
Frequently asked questions
What does ~たら~たで mean?
If... then... (new problems arise). Example: 給料が上がったら上がったで、税金も高くなる。 (If my salary goes up, then taxes also go up.)
How do you form ~たら~たで?
<Verb た-form> + ら + <same verb た-form> + で / <い-adj かったら> + <same かった> + で / <Noun / な-adj> + なら + <same> + で. Repeat the word exactly: 忙しかったら忙しかったで, not 忙しかったら忙しいで. Expect the opposite situation to be mentioned or implied first.