N1 Contrast and Concession
~としたことが: meaning, usage and examples
~としたことが means: for someone (like me)... / (un)characteristic of...
How to form it
<Noun (a person)> + としたことが
Examples
私としたことが、大事な約束を忘れるなんて。
For me to forget such an important promise...
ベテランの彼としたことが、初歩的なミスを犯すとは。
For a veteran like him to make such a basic mistake...
僕としたことが、会議の資料を間違えて印刷してしまった。
How unlike me to print the wrong materials for the meeting.
慎重な田中さんとしたことが、鍵をかけ忘れるとは珍しい。
It is unusual for someone as careful as Mr. Tanaka to forget to lock up.
When to use it
Means "for someone like me (or him) to do this, how unlike them." The speaker is surprised and disappointed that a careful or skilled person, usually themselves, made a mistake. For example, 僕としたことが、資料を間違えて印刷してしまった (how unlike me to print the wrong materials).
Nuance
Used in speech and writing, with self-reproach or surprise. Most often with 私 / 僕 or a person the speaker knows well and respects. The second half is a mistake or failure, often ending in なんて, とは or てしまった. Not used for good results.
Compare
Compare ともあろうものが: 教師ともあろうものが嘘をつくとは criticizes someone because of their social role. としたことが is personal surprise, mostly about oneself: 私としたことが鍵を忘れた. Compare にしては: 初心者にしては上手だ, a neutral "for a."
Tip: If the sentence begins with 私 and ends with a slip-up and なんて, think としたことが. For a role (教師, 警察官) being criticized, choose ともあろうものが.
More in Contrast and Concession
- ~といえども: even... / even if... / although...
- ~とはいえ: although... / nonetheless... / be that as it may...
- ~であれ / ~であろうと: whether... or... / whatever... / even if...
- ~ようが / ~ようと: no matter... / even if...
- ~ものを: even though... (expresses regret or dissatisfaction)
- ~ところを: although... / when... (polite interruption or finding)
- ~とて: even... / although... (formal)
- ~ともあろうものが: for someone (important) like... to do such a thing
- ~ないまでも: even if not... / even if one doesn't go as far as...
- ~にしたところで / ~にしたって: even for... / even if...
Frequently asked questions
What does ~としたことが mean?
For someone (like me)... / (un)characteristic of.... Example: 私としたことが、大事な約束を忘れるなんて。 (For me to forget such an important promise...)
How do you form ~としたことが?
<Noun (a person)> + としたことが. If the sentence begins with 私 and ends with a slip-up and なんて, think としたことが. For a role (教師, 警察官) being criticized, choose ともあろうものが.