N1 Uncertainty, Hedging, and Inference
~ともなく: meaning, usage and examples
~ともなく means: without really... / without intending to...
How to form it
<Verb dictionary> + ともなく + <same verb> / <Question word (+ particle)> + ともなく
Examples
テレビを見るともなく見ていたら、友達が出てきて驚いた。
I was idly watching TV when, to my surprise, a friend of mine appeared on it.
どこからともなく、いい匂いがしてきた。
A nice smell drifted in from somewhere.
窓の外を眺めるともなく眺めていると、雪が降り始めた。
As I was gazing absently out the window, it began to snow.
誰からともなく拍手が起こり、会場全体に広がった。
Applause started from no one in particular and spread through the whole hall.
When to use it
Two uses. With a repeated verb, it means doing something absently, without intending to: 「見るともなく見る」 (look without really looking). With a question word, it means "from no particular" place or person: 「どこからともなく音楽が聞こえた」. In both cases, nothing is clear or intended.
Nuance
Literary and descriptive, common in novels and essays. With verbs, it suits passive senses and thoughts: 見る, 聞く, 考える, 眺める. The action is unintended, so it is not used for deliberate effort.
Compare
ともなしに is a variant with the same meaning: 聞くともなしに聞く. ながら just means doing two things at once: テレビを見ながら食べる. ともなく stresses that there was no intention: テレビを見るともなく見ていた. With a question word, compare か: どこかから (from somewhere) is plain; どこからともなく is literary.
Tip: Remember the set phrases 見るともなく見る, 聞くともなく聞く, どこからともなく, 誰からともなく. They cover most uses you will meet.
More in Uncertainty, Hedging, and Inference
- ~と言えなくもない: it's not that you can't say... / I guess you could say...
- ~ないでもない / ~ないものでもない: it's not that... / ...is not impossible
- ~ないとも限らない: it's not impossible that... / ...might...
- ~きらいがある: to have a (negative) tendency to...
- ~とも〜とも: can't say whether... or...
- ~なりに / ~なりの: in one's own way / in accordance with...
- ~ものと思われる / ~ものと見られる: it is thought that... / it appears that... (formal inference)
Frequently asked questions
What does ~ともなく mean?
Without really... / without intending to.... Example: テレビを見るともなく見ていたら、友達が出てきて驚いた。 (I was idly watching TV when, to my surprise, a friend of mine appeared on it.)
How do you form ~ともなく?
<Verb dictionary> + ともなく + <same verb> / <Question word (+ particle)> + ともなく. Remember the set phrases 見るともなく見る, 聞くともなく聞く, どこからともなく, 誰からともなく. They cover most uses you will meet.