N1 Uncertainty, Hedging, and Inference
~とも〜とも: meaning, usage and examples
~とも〜とも means: can't say whether... or...
How to form it
<Plain form A> + とも + <Plain form B> + とも + 言わない / 言えない / つかない
Examples
彼は行くとも行かないとも言わずに帰ってしまった。
He went home without saying whether he would go or not.
その結果は、良いとも悪いとも言えない、微妙なものだった。
The result was hard to judge; you couldn't call it either good or bad.
鈴木さんは、試合に出るとも出ないとも言っていない。
Ms. Suzuki hasn't said whether she'll play in the game or not.
担当者は、計画を続けるとも中止するとも明言しなかった。
The person in charge did not make clear whether the plan would continue or be canceled.
When to use it
Lists two opposite options to say that neither one is stated or clear: "doesn't say whether A or B," "can't tell if A or B." Common pairs: 行くとも行かないとも, 良いとも悪いとも. Example: 「彼は賛成とも反対とも言わなかった」. It is common when reporting that someone gave no clear answer.
Nuance
Neutral, slightly formal. The verb that follows is almost always negative or about not saying: 言わない, 言えない, 答えない, 決まらない. It often hints that someone is being evasive or that the situation is hard to judge.
Compare
かどうか is the plain way to ask whether: 行くかどうかわからない. とも〜とも presents both options explicitly and stresses the lack of an answer: 行くとも行かないとも言わない. 〜とも〜ともつかない (neither A nor B) describes something in between: 笑いとも泣きともつかない声.
Tip: Pair two opposites, then a negative verb of saying. If the sentence ends in a positive verb, it is not this pattern.
More in Uncertainty, Hedging, and Inference
- ~と言えなくもない: it's not that you can't say... / I guess you could say...
- ~ないでもない / ~ないものでもない: it's not that... / ...is not impossible
- ~ないとも限らない: it's not impossible that... / ...might...
- ~きらいがある: to have a (negative) tendency to...
- ~ともなく: without really... / without intending to...
- ~なりに / ~なりの: in one's own way / in accordance with...
- ~ものと思われる / ~ものと見られる: it is thought that... / it appears that... (formal inference)
Frequently asked questions
What does ~とも〜とも mean?
Can't say whether... or.... Example: 彼は行くとも行かないとも言わずに帰ってしまった。 (He went home without saying whether he would go or not.)
How do you form ~とも〜とも?
<Plain form A> + とも + <Plain form B> + とも + 言わない / 言えない / つかない. Pair two opposites, then a negative verb of saying. If the sentence ends in a positive verb, it is not this pattern.