N1 Comparison and Contrast
~ならいざしらず: meaning, usage and examples
~ならいざしらず means: if it were... (it'd be different), but...
How to form it
<Noun> + ならいざしらず / <Verb plain> + (の)ならいざしらず
Examples
子供ならいざしらず、大人がそんなことをしてはダメだ。
If it were a child, it'd be different, but an adult shouldn't do such a thing.
10分や20分の遅刻ならいざしらず、1時間も待たせるなんて。
Being 10 or 20 minutes late is one thing, but making someone wait a whole hour...
素人ならいざしらず、プロがこんな初歩的な間違いをするとは。
An amateur, maybe, but for a professional to make such a basic mistake...
昔ならいざしらず、今はスマホで何でも調べられる。
That may have been true in the old days, but now you can look up anything on a smartphone.
When to use it
Sets aside one case as understandable or exceptional, then says the actual case is different and not acceptable. It works like "X would be one thing, but Y..." and the second clause usually carries criticism or surprise. Example: 子供ならいざしらず、大人がそんなことをしてはいけない (a child, maybe, but an adult should not do that).
Nuance
Formal to semi-formal, used in speech and writing. The tone is critical, often indignant. The first part is an easy or extreme case (a child, the old days, a beginner); the second part is the real situation that falls short. The second clause is often left unfinished with とは or なんて.
Compare
ならともかく has the same structure and is more everyday: 子供ならともかく、大人が…. ならいざしらず sounds more formal and more critical. はさておき only postpones a topic without contrasting cases: 冗談はさておき、本題に入ろう (joking aside, let us get to the point).
Tip: いざしらず literally means "I do not know about that." Read it as "X I could understand, but Y?" and expect a complaint to follow.
More in Comparison and Contrast
- ~にひきかえ: in contrast to... / unlike...
- ~とは打って変わって: in complete contrast to... / a complete change from...
- ~はおろか: let alone... / not to mention... / ...is out of the question
- ~もさることながら: ...is true, but...is also / not only... but also...
- ~こそ〜が/けれど: it's true that... but...
- ~こそあれ: although... / though there is...
- ~こそすれ: if anything X, but never Y / only... (never the opposite)
- ~をよそに: ignoring... / paying no attention to...
Frequently asked questions
What does ~ならいざしらず mean?
If it were... (it'd be different), but.... Example: 子供ならいざしらず、大人がそんなことをしてはダメだ。 (If it were a child, it'd be different, but an adult shouldn't do such a thing.)
How do you form ~ならいざしらず?
<Noun> + ならいざしらず / <Verb plain> + (の)ならいざしらず. いざしらず literally means "I do not know about that." Read it as "X I could understand, but Y?" and expect a complaint to follow.